Dear Editor:

Recent calls by Boothbay Harbor Waterfront Preservation (BHWP) for the recusal of the Planning Board Chair Tom Minerich have created unwarranted concerns and debate among residents and donors. These allegations are flawed and overlook the procedures our town has in place to ensure fairness and transparency.

Central to BHWP’s argument for recusal of Mr. Minerich is his home project at 51 Union Street. The town’s Code Enforcement Officer (CEO) is charged with upholding all permitting standards and would not issue permits without full compliance. To cast doubt on the process is to question the integrity not only of Mr. Minerich but of the entire town administration.

BHWP’s allegations of bias are further undermined by a simple, yet critical, fact: BHWP has not submitted an updated site plan. Without an official document or plan to evaluate, it is unreasonable to suggest that Mr. Minerich has demonstrated or could demonstrate bias regarding the project. Accusing a public official of partiality without evidence erodes trust in the very processes designed to safeguard community interests.

The ongoing delays and repeated unfounded allegations have imposed a significant emotional and financial burden on our community—Taxpayers and donors who bear the cost of these unnecessary delays. This situation is damaging, not just to Mr. Minerich’s reputation, but to the town’s image. The focus on blame and suspicion detracts from the common goal of creating a waterfront park for the enjoyment of all.

It is time for BHWP to move beyond blame and animosity. We must reaffirm our commitment to proper documentation, transparent permitting, and respectful dialogue. Common sense leadership demands that we address genuine concerns through established channels, not through public campaigns of doubt. By working together, we can ensure the completion of the Eastside Waterfront Park in a manner that honors the spirit of our community.

In closing, let us remember that our strength lies in unity and shared purpose. Rather than perpetuating divisions, we should focus our energy on collaboration and constructive problem-solving. The completion of the BHWP project should be a testament to our community’s resilience and commitment to good governance—not a casualty of misplaced suspicion and discord. Let us move forward, together, with clarity, respect, and a renewed dedication to the common good.

Jennie Mitchell Plummer

Boothbay Harbor