Is: Who knew a movie about mystery-solving, CGI sheep would make me feel the full spectrum of human emotion? “Sheep Detectives” is a classic who-dun-it that follows the titular flock of sheep detectives as they uncover the truth behind their beloved shepherd’s death. Admittedly, I was skeptical when I first heard the premise, but all my doubts were banished by the end. Yes, the film is silly, but it's also clever, heartwarming and a tearjerker.

 

To my surprise, housed within the movie’s hyper-saturated world is a profound message about grief and the importance of memory in keeping those who you have lost alive. It’s that earnestness that elevated the script and brought the water to my eyes. Judging by the sniffles I heard from my fellow moviegoers, I wasn’t the only one.

 

On a technical level, I was impressed how the visual effects team brought the motley herd to life. They struck the perfect balance between realism and letting the sheep still cartoonishly emote when needed, something that bigger budget films have failed to do.

 

While there were moments that reminded the audience the sheep were digitally rendered, such as when they jumped on things or were held by the human actors, I found myself lost in the illusion more often than not. I am a staunch believer in animation supremacy, but this is a rare case where the CGI animal/live action blend worked for me.

 

The epitome of a good old family film, “The Sheep Detectives” has something for all ages to enjoy.

 

4.5/5 shears

 

Fritz: Is and I are pretty much on the same page with this one. I was surprised by how much I enjoyed “The Sheep Detectives.” Drawn in by the novel premise and an enticing cast, I went into the theater with mediocre expectations. I expected a few chuckles out of a sloppily put-together kids' CGI-fest held up by a strong cast. Instead, I was confronted with a clever and touching film about loss, grief and acceptance.

 

Reminiscent of the 1995 classic of my childhood, “Babe,” the film has enough heart and talent to carry it beyond the bounds of its genres. It's a murder mystery safe for kids, and a kids' movie with enough intrigue and wit for adults. It was good fun. The jokes all seemed to land, and I found myself often chuckling at the sheep and their antics. The mystery elements were well planted, with just enough hints to help you guess along the way. Plus, the script was solid, the cast delivered, and the picturesque English countryside setting really drove home the charm.

 

I had two complaints. A few of the more touching moments, and one character in particular, were overt. While they worked to draw out the tears and “awws,” a more subtle approach could have gone a long way.

 

My biggest gripe was the CGI. From a technical standpoint, it was almost flawless. The talking sheep came to life and, aside from a few glitches, were believable. However, I truly questioned the need for CGI at all. I'm a dedicated fan of cartoon animation and think that a completely hand-drawn film would have brought more depth and heart. I felt CGI cheapened it.

 

Despite that, “The Sheep Detectives” was a wonderful watch. Much more than a sum of its parts, I think it's a solid film for almost anyone. I would recommend it across the board.

 

4.5/5 shears