Since Tim Lewis’ parents Carl and Mary opened it on Aug. 6, 1955, Boothbay Harbor’s Mid-Town Motel has lived up to its tagline: “A True 1950s Classic.” It’s a time capsule of mid-century Americana that stayed in the family for 66 years until its sale in 2022.  

That year, Lewis handed over the keys to Mark Osborn and Brian “Buzz” Makarewicz, who have owned the neighboring Topside Inn since 2014. 

“It was a good transition for me, knowing that someone bought it who would keep it going as it is,” said Lewis. He added, his parents would be “pleased” to see their business still in operation.  

Even when upgrading some of the facilities, the new owners ensured the 1950s branding stayed strong. This includes adding a '50s-inspired fridge and microwave to the new public kitchenette and maintaining each room’s mid-century furnishings (did you know each one has a hip new colored TV?)

Another fun nod to the decade is found in the twin bedrooms, which feature prints of Lucy and Ricky Ricardo from the popular sitcom “I Love Lucy” in reference to the era’s censorship that depicted even married couples sleeping in separate beds.  

Osborn said guests enjoy the theme commitment, and the motel only plans to get more “fun and whimsical.” “It's not like Disney World. We're not creating it. It was there. We're just trying to shine it up and show it off.” 

The guests who show their appreciation by coming back year after year are one of Osborn’s favorite parts of the job. People treat the property like home, and it’s not uncommon to see couples sitting out on the porch area, lounging with their coolers and humming radios, he said. 

Mid-Town Motel has the awards to back up its popularity. In 2015, the business received Boothbay Harbor Chamber of Commerce’s customer service award, and in 2011 was named Yankee Magazine's “Best Retro Lodging” in New England.  

Beyond the accolades, the friendships Lewis formed were the highlight for him. And he hasn't had to give those friendships up. Lewis’ home is part of the two-acre motel property, and his doorstep is a hot spot for greetings from current guests, or the grandchildren of visitors’ past.  

The motel has become an intergenerational staple alongside the area’s other long-running businesses and Lewis believes this continuity across decades showcases the region’s strengths. “It speaks well for the business owners, and also the town.”  

In honor of the motel's 70th birthday, the “Drive to 1955” promotion will be returning. Guests who stay two or more nights in May will be offered an exclusive rate of $19.55 for one night. The motel plans to have a special discount for Maine residents in June. Locals will also be able to swing into the ‘50s during the spring open house. More info to be announced soon.